While economists have questioned the viability of the idea, political analysts have been less dismissive, pointing
out that the desires of South America’s mainly leftwing presidents to promote regional integration and challenge the US dollar’s dominance should not be underestimated. For the first time in more than seven years, Brazil and Argentina are politically aligned under leftist leaders, with both Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and Alberto Fernández keen to present a united front. Brazil’s president said in Buenos Aires last week that «God willing», the finance ministers and leaders of the two central banks would have the «intelligence, competence and good sense» to begin work that could eventually produce a common currency. His Argentine counterpart said while he did not know how the common currency would work, the two nations would enjoy a «deeper strategic bond» in the future.
The two leaders made clear an eventual common currency would, at first, be limited to use in trade and would run in tandem with Brazil’s real and the Argentine peso, rather than replacing them. This is not the first time that the idea has been floated. People close to the previous rightwing administration in Brazil confirmed that former finance minister Paulo Guedes had defended the idea several times on the grounds the currency would help impose fiscal discipline and that there would be fewer global currencies in the future, so it would be beneficial if the region established its own. Latin America’s left has long wanted to reduce the region’s historic dependence on the US and sees a common currency as a clever way to claim greater economic sovereignty while also pursuing a long-held dream of closer political union.
In a nod to those tensions with its rival north of the equator, Brazil’s current finance minister, Fernando Haddad, last year co-authored a piece suggesting a common currency called the «sur», or south. Underpinning the political support is a desire to stabilise Argentina’s battered economy. «Argentina needs an external anchor to restore credibility,» said economist Rodrigo Wagner, an expert on new currency adoption. At roughly $30bn in 2022, flows between Brazil and Argentina are lower than the $40bn level recorded a decade ago.
«Brazil wants a larger market for its exports and to lower trade barriers,» he said. A common unit of exchange would be an «ultimate vehicle» towards achieving both. Buenos Aires has been cut off from international debt markets since a default in 2020 and has tight foreign exchange controls. The real, meanwhile, is fully convertible, and a better grip on government spending means that Brazil has full access to international markets.
Annual inflation in Argentina reached 94.8 per cent in December, against a far more manageable 5.79 per cent in Brazil. «My perception is this common currency is not going to be feasible. » .
Comments
Post a Comment